One sale with Tier 1 and Tier 2 lots: options for RedBird
Nov 19, 2026
We recommend that one franchise sale can carry both Tier 1 and Tier 2 lots, with Tier 1 approval checked per lot. In a mixed sale, Tier 1 lots close in the live close and Tier 2 lots close timed. Everyday timed sales stay Tier 2 only.
The decision
Can one sale, for example a franchise sale, hold both Tier 1 and Tier 2 lots? Or does each sale carry one tier only, so a franchise runs as two sales?
Tier 1 lots need Tier 1 approval to bid. Tier 2 lots are open to any bidder with a line. Tier 1 approval is given once per bidder, as agreed on 18 Nov, so later Tier 1 sales open automatically.
A · Yes, approval per lot. One sale carries both tiers; each Tier 1 lot asks for Tier 1 approval.
B · No, one tier per sale. A franchise runs as two sales, one Tier 1 and one Tier 2.
What you told us
On 18 Nov you described both kinds of sale, and said the launch will coincide with a Tier 1 sale.
Hero items from older productions, sold apart from new-production launches: "there will be hero things that we're selling independently of", "where we get something from a production in 1980 that we think is a high ticket item along with another, a few others."
Franchise sales: "maybe we do a Star Trek ... a Star Trek auction" and "it'll depend on, on what we find."
Launch: "launch with some big ticket items" and "it's definitely all gonna coincide with, with a tier one sale."
How others do it
Houses do both, for different jobs. For their regular flow they split sales by price level. For studio and franchise events they put every price level in one sale, and gate the top lots one by one.
| House or sale | What they do | Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Sotheby's | Lots marked ✧ ("Premium Lots") inside a sale need a pre-registration application; references and a deposit may be asked. "Some auctions and lots require additional financial verification such as a bank reference." | Gate per lot |
| Heritage x HBO, Game of Thrones (Oct 2024) | One studio sale, 912 lots in three live sessions, every price level. Sold out at $21,115,718 per Heritage's release, with 32 lots at six figures | One sale, all levels |
| Julien's x TCM | 1,400+ items in one sale; top lots $260,000 and $130,000 | One sale, all levels |
| Christie's x CBS Paramount, Star Trek, 2006 (press) | 1,000 lots in one sale, $7.1M in total. A Borg cube expected to fetch no more than $1,500 sold for $96,000; the Enterprise-D model sold for $576,000 | One sale, all levels |
| Goldin | Separate sales by level: Elite for lots estimated at $7,500+, Weekly for $100+ | Split by sale |
| Heritage | Signature sales with a printed catalogue and live bidding; weekly Internet sales online only. No value criteria published. Its luxury real estate live session needs a $100,000 deposit or proof of funds | Split by sale |
| Christie's online sales | One bidding limit across the whole online sale | Gate per bidder |
| HBO at Heritage, Succession, Jan 2024 (press) | A volume studio sale run online on its own: 236 lots, top lot $25,000 | Separate sale |
The studio sales closest to RedBird's model all mixed price levels in one sale, and the low lots did not hold them back: in the Star Trek sale, a lot expected to fetch no more than $1,500 sold for $96,000. The Star Trek and Succession figures come from press, as we could not open the houses' own pages for those sales.
Options compared
A keeps the franchise as one event and brings hero traffic to everyday lots; B gives the cleanest hero presentation at the cost of two catalogues per franchise.
| A · One sale, approval per lot (recommended) | B · One tier per sale | |
|---|---|---|
| Collectors | One franchise catalogue. Tier 2 bidders see the hero lots; only bidders without Tier 1 approval meet the approval step, once | Two catalogues per franchise; Tier 2 bidders may never visit the hero sale |
| Consignors and studios | One event and one press push; hero traffic reaches the everyday lots | Two marketing pushes per franchise; the hero sale stands alone |
| Revenue | More eyes on Tier 2 lots from hero traffic, to be measured | Tier 2 lots rely on their own marketing |
| Risk | Hero lots can look cheapened next to low lots; handled by leading with hero lots and giving them their own live close | Low brand risk |
| Operations | A tier flag and a close type (live or timed) on every lot | Two sale set-ups per franchise |
| Fits what you told us | Franchise sales, e.g. "a Star Trek auction" | A high-ticket hero piece sold "along with ... a few others" |
Our recommendation and why
We recommend A, approval per lot, with two guardrails:
In a mixed franchise sale, Tier 1 lots close in the live close and Tier 2 lots close timed. Each lot page shows its tier and how it closes.
Everyday timed sales stay Tier 2 only.
A one-off hero piece, like the 1980 production piece you described on 18 Nov, can still run as a Tier 1-only sale. Your auction side decides, per lot, which lots go into the live close.
Why A:
The closest benchmarks mixed levels. Game of Thrones at Heritage, Star Trek at Christie's and Julien's x TCM each sold every price level in one sale.
The tool already exists at the top of the market. Sotheby's marks Premium Lots inside a sale and asks for pre-registration to bid on those lots. That is option A.
B belongs to the regular flow, which RedBird already has. Goldin and Heritage split premium and weekly sales by value; RedBird's everyday timed sales do the same job.
What your auction side may push back on, and our answer:
"Hero lots belong in their own sale." Agreed for one-off heroes. For a franchise sale, one banner with two visibly different closes keeps the hero framing: hero lots lead the catalogue and close live.
"Per-lot approval adds friction." Tier 1 approval is once per bidder, so only bidders new to Tier 1 meet the step, and they can start it from the lot page.
"We want control of the live close." You get it: the close type is a per-lot switch for your auction side.
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio takes on:
A Tier 1 or Tier 2 setting on every lot, and a live or timed close setting per lot within a sale.
A Tier 1 badge on the lot page, and an approval prompt for bidders who do not yet have Tier 1 approval.
Mixed-sale catalogues that lead with the hero lots and show each lot's close clearly.
We need from you:
Per sale, which lots are Tier 1 and which go into the live close.
The first franchise sale, once you have archive access.
How we'll measure it
We report these after every mixed sale:
Bidders per lot and sell-through for Tier 2 lots in mixed sales, against Tier 2-only timed sales.
Tier 1 approvals started from a lot page in a mixed sale.
Hero lot prices against estimate.
Sources
Sotheby's, Guide for Buyers (updated 6 Nov 2026), read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Game of Thrones results release (13 Oct 2024), read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Game of Thrones sale page, auction 7366, read 19 Nov 2026
Julien's, Julien's Auctions and TCM results, read 17 Nov 2026
Goldin, About, read 19 Nov 2026
Heritage, Auction types, read 19 Nov 2026
Christie's, online conditions of sale, Geneva (May 2024), read 16 Nov 2026
Press, no house page available: Slice of SciFi on Christie's Star Trek sale (8 Oct 2006), read 17 Nov 2026
Press, no house page opened: NBC New York (AP) on the Succession sale, read 17 Nov 2026